• About
    • Educational Philosophy
    • Research
  • Courses
    • Science 9
    • Environmental Science 20
      • Nature of Environmental Science
      • Atmospheric Systems: Air Quality and Climate Change
      • Human Population
      • Aquatic Systems
      • Terrestrial Ecosystems
    • Gaming Education
      • RPG Maker 2000
    • Gender and Sexual Diversity 20
      • Deepening the Discussion Toolkit – Ministry of Education SK
      • NFB – Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Media
    • Health Science 20
      • Health Care Philosophies and Ethics
      • Nutrition
      • Human Body
      • Diagnostics and Treatment
    • Biology 30
      • Characteristics of Life
      • Cell Processes
      • Anatomy and Physiology of Multicellular Organisms
      • Genetics and Chromosomes
    • AP® Biology
      • Course Outline and Introduction Assignment
      • AP Biology Exam Prep
      • Big Idea 1: Evolution
      • Big Idea 2: Biological Systems and Energy
        • Energy-Related Pathways
      • Big Idea 3: Information Storage and Transfer
      • Big Idea 4: Biological Interactions
      • Blog Post Information
  • Podcasts
    • Learning Together – A Prairie South Podcast
  • Presentations
  • Education Blog
    • Science Education
      • One of an Infinite Means to Approach Science, Education, and the Universe: Part 1 – Nature of Science
      • One of an Infinite Means to Approach Science, Education, and the Universe: Part 2 – Objectivity, Subjectivity, and Perspective
      • One of an Infinite Means to Approach Science, Education, and the Universe: Part 3 – Life & Kinship
      • One of an Infinite Means to Approach Science, Education, and the Universe: Part 4 – Science Education
      • Developing a high school science digital citizenship resource
      • Maximizing Education for Digital Literacy
      • Scientific Literacy and Digital Citizenship Lessons
      • Digital Literacy in Saskatchewan Science: A Curriculum Guide
    • ECI 832 – Digital Citizenship & Literacy
      • Maximizing Education for Digital Literacy
      • Digital Learners and Digital Wisdom in a Digital World
      • Transgenerational (Digital) Citizenship Education
      • Developing a high school science digital citizenship resource
      • Digital Identity: Past, Present, Future
      • The Need for Media Literacy
      • Can we ever be “fully literate” in all dimensions of literacy?
      • My critical, digital life.
      • A Media Literate Rhapsody
    • ECI 834 – Distance Education
      • Closing the distance between distance education and myself.
      • (re)Creating a virtual educator.
      • LMS or VLE? Don’t matter to me! Canvas? Let’s see.
      • Can an educator become YouTube famous? Creating, comparing and critiquing an educational Vlog.
      • Blended learner = blended educator.
      • Barriers to blended/hybrid/mixed-mode/distributed learning.
      • Online community-buildin’ probs (problems).
      • Agoraphobia in education.
      • Module-making: finishing touches to going worldwide.
      • Teaching for EVERYBODY.
    • ECI 833 – Educational Technology
      • Can’t fight the #EdTech juggernaut.
      • Learning as a chaotic, evolving mosaic.
      • The digital life of a teacher-entertainer.
      • Educational software is changing for us, and us for it.
      • Stop villainizing the internet.
      • Distance education: bringing the Mr. Petlak Classroom Experience Worldwide?
      • Determining pros and cons myself of modern internet learning as self-determination.
      • I’m not secretive, I’m Socrative; Assessing Assessment Tools.
      • Assistive technology knows no bounds!
      • A whole new world: virtual and augmented reality.
      • Ed Tech is/has always been about us and our learners.
    • ECI 831 – Social Media and Open Education
      • ECI 831 – Major Project – Piano
        • Synthesia and Pre-Assessing My Piano Skills
        • Let the chords be with you.
        • Piano: Don’t cut (chord) corners.
        • Learnin’ piano on the go, bro!
        • Revelations: feedback and music/language learning
        • Piano injuries: movement retraining.
        • Learning piano: Patience, hard work and connections that transcend time.
      • How I overcame #edtech anxiety.
      • Being a devil’s advocate teacher.
      • I M Connected. R U? U R?! GR8.
      • “You’re born a teacher”. Making teaching a science?
      • When your teacher Snapchats in class.
      • Why do Students Snapchat? Intimacy and Connectedness.
      • Harnessing social media: anonymity and digital citizenship
      • Fundamental rights of open education.
      • Looking at the digital educator narrative, wearing Googles.
      • Net neutrality, safety in ambiguity, equity, and a digital(ly) divide(y).
      • Normalcy and “justifying” online harassment
      • Sharing an idea: the perks of Slacktivism
      • ED Goals: Continue to connect, learn, question and improve.
    • ECI 830 – Issues in EdTech
      • Defining what exactly #EdTech is.
      • EdTech in class doesn’t just enhance learning, it IS learning.
      • Just Google it? Just Google it right. Building from simple to complex.
      • Games, technology and student learning and well-being
      • Sharing and openness. A moral imperative, even on social media.
      • Social media IS childhood.
      • Good intentions and what is morally just make EdTech equitable.
      • Should you sell your educating soul for the right reason (students)?
      • Dialled in, plugged in, and loving life.
      • Educate and you will be gold.
  • Health Ed Resources
    • Be There Certificate
    • Mental Health Literacy (TeenMentalHealth)
    • Canadian Guidelines for Sexual Health Education
    • Deepening the Discussion: Gender and Sexual Diversity
    • Teaching Sexual Health
      • Teaching Sexuality Wheel
    • Sex & U
      • Sex & U – Contraception Methods Booklet
    • Planned Parenthood
  • EdTech: Resources & Tools
    • General Resources
      • Google Read&Write
      • Pixton – Comic Creator
      • Comic Life – (Free Trial)
      • Flocabulary
      • Super Teacher Worksheets
      • Remind – Messaging Tool
    • Assessment Tools
      • Kahoot!
      • Socrative
      • Seesaw
    • Science & Math Resources
      • Let’s Talk Science
      • Nutrients for Life
      • Zorbits Math
      • Teach Engineering: STEM Science Lessons
      • Prodigy – Math Game
      • Math Tasks for Sask Curriculum (AirTable)
      • MathUp
      • Secondary Science Implementation Support – Resources
      • Gizmos – Science & Math Simulations – Subscription Required
      • BioInteractive – Science Activities
      • PhET – Interactive Science Simulations
      • OISE – Indigenous Ways of Knowing
      • Science Current Events Sites
        • Science News for Students
        • IFLScience
        • EurekAlert!
    • Teaching Typing
      • Typing.com
      • Typing Club
    • Coding
      • SaskCode
      • CodinGame
      • CS First
      • Scratch
      • Code Combat
    • Digital Citizenship
      • Digital Citizenship Education in Saskatchewan Schools
      • TeachThought
      • Crash Course Navigating Digital Information
      • Common Sense Education
      • Media Smarts
      • Web Literacy for Student Fact-Checkers
      • Interland – A Digital Citizenship Game
    • Open Education
      • OER Commons
      • Open Stax
      • Open Textbook Library
      • Open Text BC
      • EdX: Free Open Online Courses
      • Coursera

Logan Petlak

~ Lifelong Learner.

Logan Petlak

Tag Archives: politics and education

The Illusion of Providing Neutral Education

25 Tuesday Feb 2020

Posted by loganpetlak in Education Blog

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

critical literacy, education, politics and education

Providing Neutral Education Woes

“I try to present the information as neutral”, said a friend and colleague of mine as they engaged their History 10 students in a discussion about various forms of government as part of the political decision-making outcomes, to which you could see and hear students respond to the different political ideologies with fervor as it aligned or contrasted with their developing beliefs. It would be ignorant for me to assume that all teachers try to “present the information as neutral” on a consistent basis, but I would propose that many do. The very thought of trying to collect data and transcripts detailing every conversation in every classroom in Saskatchewan is overwhelming. Nonetheless, my colleague’s intent to be neutral is noble, and is a shared, daunting task for many educators worldwide… even though to be completely neutral is impossible for any individual.

Educators regularly tow the line of delivering content in a means that is “as neutral as possible”, and this is lined with fears about accidentally saying the “wrong thing” or “too much” (sometimes this dialogue has the potential to tarnish public perception of education). While it is unfortunate that they have this fear (educators aren’t alone in this), tact and consideration before speaking is a valuable skill, specifically in today’s social climate, as well as considering the implications of your words (but more on this topic another time). However, this means that educators don’t feel the freedom to speak candidly on topics that may be relevant to curriculum or based on the learning interests of the students. That being said, parents and other community members are right to care about their student’s education and advocating for multiple perspectives in education in the classroom. While hopes are that parents and teachers can continue to build trust between one another and develop an open discourse, this is sometimes countered through the proclaimed pursuit of neutral or “politic-free” education which, as I mentioned above, is impossible.

Why is Neutral or Politic-Free Education Impossible?

The sum total of your lived experiences (culture, biology, trauma, etc.) influences your identity and, by extension, your opinions and daily interactions with everyone. One can hold the belief that they can shelter or hide their identity or political beliefs from others, but the reality is that your conservative, liberal, nationalist, or globalist views are an important part of who you are that are reflected in your actions, words and life. This bias is reflected in any communication that occurs with others which includes educator-student, parent-student, or parent-educator. Bias is often used negatively, and while it is a confounding factor in society, it is a reality (even in artificial intelligence design), and taking steps to avoid it promotes self-awareness. When considering this in addressing educational curriculum-writing and the potential political implications of curricular content, it becomes clear the futility in attempting to achieve the neutral or politic-free ideal.

Addressing Neutral (Non-Political) Education Promotion: Climate Change

“We’ll get politics out of the classroom” is a phrase that is shared and held by individuals in Saskatchewan and Alberta. While the potential intent is to have teachers be less politically-biased in the instruction of students, acknowledging the potentially manipulative nature of education; education does influence the worldview of students. Completely removing bias is an impossible task academically, professionally and personally, especially when curricula is composed of outcomes related to relevant topics and issues that are inherently political, for example:

ES20-AH2
Analyze the production, reliability and uses of geoscience data to investigate the effects of a changing climate on society and the environment.

Saskatchewan Curriculum – Environmental Science 20.

This is a climate change outcome, a contentious topic in media. Data can be presented to students regarding the investigation “of the effects of a changing climate”, however, the selection of data provided to students, including the source and amount of evidence provided, is inescapably biased regardless of the educator’s stance. This is exacerbated when students likely are approaching the content biased, having already been exposed via their social networks to topic-relevant information. This climate change outcome also highlights how navigating it as educators is increasingly complicated when you live in a resource-based economy heavily influenced by the fossil fuel industry.

It’s important to acknowledge that the fossil fuel industry contributes to the livelihood of many families in Canada and its disruption has the potential to negatively impact these people. However, it’s also important to note that climate science education isn’t meant to belittle the work of fossil fuel-sector employees or undervalue the importance of these resources to energy-production, manufacturing and associated products.

When investigating geoscience data, which can be done through textbooks or a multitude of online sources informed from peer-reviewed articles, most evidence (scientific consensus) points towards anthropogenic climate change and that the Earth’s overall climate is warming. Extending further, when challenging students to analyze sources for reliability, many of the sources fulfill the best practices for evaluating sources for credibility and reliability. As students synthesize this information, it may appear that the educator is pushing their kids to be pro-climate change, even if they attempt to deliver content from opposing viewpoints. However, when applying outcomes and intents of the curriculum including scientific literacy and “engaged citizens”, neutrality on this political topic becomes impossible, but is not presented this way in media and therefore not interpreted this way by members of the community.

Media presentation of topics like climate change may widen generational divides between youth and previous generations or foster distrust between educators and community members concerned about their student’s education. Most media is created and worded to generate a reaction (“likes, shares, and clicks”) and unfortunately, at times, this incites division, in this case between the public and the education system. Division may then be taken advantage of by parties who seek to gain from this, of which guilt can be assigned regardless of an individual’s affiliation. Oddly enough, both sides normally have the same goal, which is “what’s best for the student”, but each side, at times, fail to recognize that reality in the “opposing” party, and may forfeit critical thinking due to their personal, inescapable biases. All of this highlights the complications of promoting “neutral” education as a political tactic, rather than the promotion of critical thinking to create informed citizens.

Not Being Neutral is Important
Paulo Freire 1977

Critical thinking is an imperative in today’s connected world and many resources are available to help promote this, even though many conventions of society sway us to drift away from it, such as advertisements. As curriculum becomes renewed, critical thinking increasingly is a focal point in curricular writing. However, this may result in coming to a definitive conclusion on a topic that may influence political decision-making, a consequence of critical thinking, which is not neutral. To paraphrase Paulo Friere (pictured to the right) from Pedagogy of the Oppressed, educators can’t be neutral, and this is exacerbated when promoting critical thinking. Further to this point, to attempt to be neutral is to be complicit in issues, be they about politics, social justice, environment, or others.

This presents the importance of the educator’s role in improving their personal critical thinking skills, addressing curricular topics through this lens in their classroom, and the inherent modelling to students of an informed opinion and generating an open, respectful dialogue on these topics.

To extend this further, it’s what the students want from their teachers. In my experience living and working in education in Saskatchewan (which I acknowledge is an isolated subjective, personal experience), students want to know what their teacher’s opinions are on topics and current issues in society. It builds student-educator relationships, but it puts a lot of pressure on the tact used by the teacher in these scenarios. The teacher is in a unique position, as how they deliver that opinion will undoubtedly influence the student (this is sometimes referred to as hidden curriculum). It becomes important that the teacher still respects opposing viewpoints or individuals (for example, even if you oppose a particular political leader, your rhetoric needs to be respectful and critical). I understand that administrators and some experts may feel that this is best avoided due to the influential role of the teacher, but I, once again, posit that this influence is unavoidable. As educators, this presentation of a (hopefully) respectful and informed opinion is fundamental component of creating engaged citizens. The variations in which this occurs from classroom to classroom helps learners refine their own views, ideally in this critical, intersectional approach. However, this falls short in the absence of additional education from family and community members. “It takes a village” to create more critically literate learners. Through the promotion of an open, respectful dialogue, and a lack of neutrality without forfeiting self-awareness and open-mindedness, society may become more critically literate.


This post was written on Treaty 4 territory, the original lands of the Cree,
Ojibwe, Saulteaux, Dakota, Nakota, Lakota, and on the homeland of the Métis Nation. This acknowledgement is made to recognize harm and mistakes of the past, their impact on the present, and an ongoing commitment to the pursuit of reconciliation and partnerships with Indigenous Nations.

The author’s social context is that of a caucasian (predominantly Eastern European ancestry), cisgendered, straight male (pronouns He/Him), born and raised in an English-speaking, middle-class family in Saskatchewan, Canada. These details are included to present potential influences and privileges associated with the author.

Links to sources of content are embedded into document.

Learn about the author here.

Logan Petlak

Incredible day! Photo courtesy Julia and Lucas Photography

Follow Logan Petlak on WordPress.com

Contact Info

650 Coteau St W,
Moose Jaw, SK
Treaty 4 territory
13066931331
petlak.logan@prairiesouth.ca
Regular school hours.

Recent Posts

  • Podcasts to be released soon!
  • The Illusion of Providing Neutral Education
  • Digital Literacy in Saskatchewan Science: A Curriculum Guide
  • Scientific Literacy and Digital Citizenship Lessons
  • A Media Literate Rhapsody

Recent Comments

Let’s Dive Into Prod… on Stop villainizing the int…
loganpetlak on Can an educator become YouTube…
Bhuboy on Can an educator become YouTube…
loganpetlak on A Media Literate Rhapsody
loganpetlak on A Media Literate Rhapsody

Archives

  • October 2021
  • February 2020
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016

Categories

  • AP Biology
  • Biology 30
  • CCIAPBiology
  • ECI 830
  • ECI 831
  • ECI 831 – Major Project – Learning Piano
  • ECI 831 – Major Project – Piano
  • ECI 832
  • ECI 833
  • ECI 834
  • eci831
  • Education Blog
  • Science Education
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Categories

What are you looking for?

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Logan Petlak
    • Join 43 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Logan Petlak
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar